Nedbank ordered to pay costs after South African court sets aside home loan judgment

Feyisayo Ajayi
Feyisayo Ajayi
Nedbank

Nedbank, one of South Africa’s five largest, top-tier financial services groups, has been ordered to pay the legal costs of two Soweto homeowners after the High Court in Johannesburg set aside a 2021 default judgment that had declared their home specially executable.

The judgment, delivered by Judge S D J Wilson on October 1, 2026, found that Nedbank had failed to meaningfully engage with Karabo Nobuhle Modibedi and Cecilia Mamoabi Modibedi after they requested a restructuring of their mortgage repayments.

Court overturns 2021 mortgage judgment

The Modibedis had borrowed just over R270,000 ($16.219) from the lender in 2008, secured against their home in Mofolo, Soweto. They made regular payments for about a decade before experiencing financial difficulties in 2018.

After Nedbank issued a notice under section 129 of South Africa’s National Credit Act, the homeowners responded through a local paralegal organisation in October 2020, asking to restructure their repayment obligations.

Nedbank subsequently issued summons and obtained a default judgment in October 2021 for just over R310,000 ($18,627), together with an order declaring the property specially executable. The court found that the lender could not establish that it had meaningfully considered the restructuring proposal before pursuing the judgment.

Nedbank call log fails to establish engagement

Nedbank relied on a call log to demonstrate that it had engaged with the homeowners. Judge Wilson found the document inadequate, noting that it contained unexplained acronyms and shorthand and did not identify who had spoken to the applicants.

The court also found that the call log did not demonstrate genuine consideration of the homeowners’ request for a restructured payment plan. The Modibedis had explained that although they were unemployed, rental income from tenants on the property could be used to make reduced mortgage payments. The court found that Nedbank did not appear to have meaningfully considered that proposal and instead appeared focused on encouraging the homeowners to sell the property.

National Credit Act weighs on Nedbank’s case

Nedbank Group, one of South Africa’s five largest, top-tier financial services groups, carries a market value of R136 billion ($8.18 billion) on the JSE, ranking 26th overall and fifth among South African banks with operations across Southern Africa and international offices in London, Dubai, and Jersey.

Because the Modibedis had responded by seeking a repayment arrangement, Judge Wilson found that Nedbank was required to meaningfully engage with their proposal before approaching the court. The court consequently ruled that the 2021 judgment had been “erroneously sought and granted” and rescinded it under Rule 42 of the Uniform Rules of Court.

Judge Wilson also expressed doubts about whether executing against the home would be proportionate given the homeowners’ circumstances and the comparatively modest amount secured against the property. Nedbank was ordered to pay the costs of the rescission application, including counsel’s costs on scale B.

Nedbank
Share This Article