Dipula Property Fund defeats NEMISA bid to recover rental deposit

Feyisayo Ajayi
Feyisayo Ajayi
Dipula Property

Dipula Property Fund, an internally managed Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT) listed on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE), has secured a legal victory after the Johannesburg High Court dismissed an application by the National Electronic Media Institute of South Africa (NEMISA) to join four trustees of the Dipula Property Investment Trust to a lawsuit over a R1.2 million ($69,562) rental deposit.

Acting Judge Abrahams ruled on November 13, 2026, that NEMISA’s proposed claim against the trustees had prescribed, finding that the organisation had sufficient information to identify the trust as the landlord and investigate its trustees before launching its original legal proceedings.

Rental deposit dispute dates back to 2010

The dispute stems from a commercial lease concluded in 2010 for premises in Parktown, Johannesburg, under which NEMISA paid a security deposit of R1.35 million. The agreement identified Dipula Property Fund, founded with a R300 million portfolio, and the Dipula Property Investment Trust as the landlord, with Java Capital Trustees acting as trustee.

The lease continued through subsequent extensions and temporary accommodation arrangements before NEMISA’s occupation ended on May 31, 2022. After termination, NEMISA sought a refund of its deposit, claiming that R147,082 had been deducted for additional restoration work, leaving R1.205 million outstanding, excluding accrued interest.

The organisation calculated that the refund became due within 90 days of termination, on August 29, 2022. After payment was not received, it instituted proceedings on May 20, 2025, against Dipula Property Fund and Java Capital Trustees.

NEMISA sought to add four trust trustees

Both defendants denied liability. Java Capital Trustees argued that it had acted as an agent of the trust rather than as a principal contracting party.

NEMISA subsequently applied to join four trustees of the Dipula Property Investment Trust, arguing that it only established the trust’s position as the principal landlord after receiving the defendants’ plea in July 2025.

The trustees opposed the application, maintaining that the original lease documents had expressly identified the trust as landlord. They argued that NEMISA could have established the trustees’ identities earlier and that the three-year prescription period had already expired.

Court finds proposed claim had prescribed

Abrahams agreed with the trustees, finding that the trust had been identified as landlord in the 2010 lease and subsequent agreements. The judge also rejected NEMISA’s reliance on a property search that did not display any trustees, noting that this did not demonstrate that the trust no longer existed.

The court held that NEMISA could have approached the Master’s office to establish the trustees’ identities before instituting its original action. Discovering their identities later did not restart the prescription period.

It further ruled that the original proceedings against Dipula Property Fund and Java Capital Trustees did not interrupt prescription of the separate proposed claim against the trust through its trustees. The application to join the trustees could not itself constitute the legal process required to interrupt prescription under section 15(1) of the Prescription Act.

Ruling leaves underlying liability unresolved

The court concluded that the three-year prescription period expired on August 29, 2025, meaning NEMISA’s proposed claim against the trustees had prescribed.

However, the ruling does not finally determine whether Dipula Property Fund or Java Capital Trustees is liable for repayment of the outstanding rental deposit. It addresses only NEMISA’s attempt to introduce the trust’s trustees into the proceedings after the applicable prescription period had expired.

Dipula Property Fund
Dipula Property Fund
Share This Article