M&G opposes Grant Pattison’s nomination to SPAR board    

M&G, which owns just over 14% of SPAR, said Pattison’s resignation from Pick n Pay on Oct. 29 does not resolve its concerns about his suitability for a board position at a direct competitor.

Timilehin Adejumobi
Timilehin Adejumobi
Former Massmart and Edcon CEO Grant Pattison

M&G Investments, a global asset manager and Spar shareholder, has opposed the appointment of former Massmart and Edcon CEO Grant Pattison to the retailer’s board, escalating a governance dispute over leadership, board independence and the absence of independent retailer representation. The investment manager argues that his recent position at rival Pick n Pay creates an unacceptable conflict. 

M&G, which owns just over 14% of SPAR, said Pattison’s resignation from Pick n Pay on Oct. 29 does not resolve its concerns about his suitability for a board position at a direct competitor. The fund manager also holds a substantial stake in Pick n Pay, making the relationship particularly sensitive.

M&G pushes for board changes 

The investment manager has called for an extraordinary general meeting to elect five nonexecutive directors, including two independent retailers, arguing that SPAR needs a broader range of commercial, retail and governance experience. In a statement Monday, M&G said the board’s composition required urgent attention and that the proposed appointments did not address its concerns. 

M&G is proposing turnaround specialist Phil Roux, former PwC chartered accountant and Shoprite group lead auditor Anton Wentzel, independent SPAR retailer George Skoutellas, former Media24 CEO and CFO Omnichand Lalbahadur, and former SPAR CEO Angelo Swartz for election to the board. 

SPAR appointed acting chair Lwazi Koyana as permanent chairman on Nov. 12 and elected Pattison as a director, with his appointment scheduled to take effect Feb. 25, 2027. The following day, the company disclosed that Roux had rejected an offer to join the board, prompting M&G to intensify its campaign for an extraordinary shareholder vote.

Pick n Pay connection raises concerns 

Pattison, who led Massmart when Walmart acquired a 51% stake in the retailer, has extensive experience in South Africa’s retail industry. However, M&G’s objection centres on the prospect of him moving from the board of Pick n Pay, where he served for about eight months, to SPAR, a direct competitor. 

“We cannot endorse a director moving from one company’s board to a direct competitor’s board. That is our position,” M&G equity analyst Damon Buss said, explaining the investment manager’s opposition. 

Buss said M&G had raised its governance concerns when Pattison’s departure from Pick n Pay was announced and shareholders were informed that he was being considered for the SPAR board. The fund manager believes appointing him would create an unacceptable overlap between two competing retailers in which it has significant investments. 

Pattison said he respected the board’s decision to nominate him and acknowledged that shareholders had the final say. He said investors would have opportunities to express their views at both the extraordinary general meeting and the annual general meeting before his appointment takes effect.

Debt adds to SPAR’s pressure

The governance dispute is unfolding as SPAR struggles with rising debt, weaker profitability and competition from on-demand grocery delivery platforms. The company’s half-year results for 2026 showed net debt climbing to R7.3 billion ($433.36 million) from R5.4 billion ($320.5 million) at the end of September 2025, while operating profit fell 45% to R740.5 million ($44 million) in its half-year results. 

The Spar Guild of Southern Africa has publicly backed Roux, Swartz and Skoutellas for board positions, saying retailers want meaningful board renewal and directors with direct knowledge of the group’s independent retail model. The guild also welcomed M&G’s move to convene an extraordinary general meeting. 

It said Skoutellas would bring the perspective of an independent retailer, while Swartz’s former leadership experience would help address the relationship between SPAR and its franchisees. Roux, meanwhile, was backed for his experience in turning around underperforming businesses and understanding the importance of restoring independent retailer profitability.

The guild also expressed support for Koyana as chairman, indicating that the retailers’ campaign is focused on board composition rather than an outright rejection of the current leadership.

SPAR turnaround faces pressure 

Roux rejected SPAR’s board offer on Nov. 12 after the company failed to meet conditions he had set, although he said Monday he believed he could have sufficient shareholder backing to secure those terms. His potential return to discussions adds another layer to the contest over the retailer’s future leadership. 

SPAR operates a wholesale, warehousing and distribution network supplying more than 4,500 stores, most independently owned, across South Africa and international markets. Its operations extend into Southern Africa, Ireland, Switzerland and Poland, with a joint venture in Sri Lanka, making relationships with independent retailers central to its business model and recovery prospects.

M&G Investments is a leading global active asset manager and a flagship business of M&G plc, an international savings and investment group listed on the London Stock Exchange (LSE: MNG) and a constituent of the FTSE 100 Index.

Share This Article